Gun Violence: Scapegoating Mental Illness

“This is a political choice that we make, to allow this to happen every few months in America.” —President Barak Obama, October 1, 2015

Jonathan M. Metzl and Kenneth T. MacLeish published “Mental Illness, Mass Shootings, and the Politics of American Firearms” in the 105th volume of the American Journal of Public Health, February 2015.

Why the study? Political responses to mass shootings in the U.S. tend to focus on the causal relationship between mental health and gun violence. Some recent responses have gone as far as to require mental health professionals to report “dangerous patients” so that authorities can confiscate their firearms. Even though the authors agree that mental illness was a factor in many mass shootings and that addressing it is important, their research aims to challenge the oversimplification of claims about gun violence that frame the discussion so that the problem of everyday gun violence in the U.S. is obscured.

Results of the study? The authors point to 4 assumptions that underlie political responses to gun violence as they relate to mental health: (1) mental illness causes gun violence, (2) a psychiatric diagnosis can predict gun crime, (3) the unhinged acts of mentally ill loners cause shootings, and (4) gun regulation will not stop mass shootings. Even though each of these claims could be true in a particular case, the research as a whole (1970-2014) shows that

  • Oversimplification creates stereotypes in the vast, diverse population of persons with mental illness
  • How mental illness is understood after mass shootings highlights broader cultural issues and anxieties (like race and class)
  • Those broader issues are obscured when the mentally ill are scapegoated
  • Mass shootings tend to inaccurately represent all gun crime
  • “Mental illness” inaccurately represents a violent threat rather than a medical designation.

Quick summary? The study consists of a review and analysis of over 40 years of research in psychiatry, psychology, public health, and sociology related to gun violence and mental health. The review and analysis also included the authors’ own primary source historical research on race/ethnicity, violence, mental illness, and US gun culture. Framing the discussion about gun violence as a mental illness issue distracts attention away from “community-level everyday violence and the widespread symptoms produced by living in an environment engulfed by fear of guns and shootings.” The inherent promise that mental health professionals can solve gun violence also places the responsibility for prevention squarely on their backs. Ultimately, the argument that gun control won’t stop another mass shooting mistakenly assumes that that is the goal of gun control policies.

Take-aways?

So what?

  • With this knowledge, news consumers can be more critical of causal oversimplifications about gun violence
  • With this knowledge, advocates can present more sophisticated arguments for or against gun regulation
  • With this knowledge, journalists can offer context-rich accounts of gun violence and its potential causes

Jonathan M. Metzl, M.D., Ph.D. is with the Center for Medicine, Health, and Society and the Departments of Sociology and Psychiatry at Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN. Kenneth T. MacLeish, Ph.D. is with the Center for Medicine, Health, and Society and the Department of Anthropology at Vanderbilt University. Correspondence should be sent to Jonathan M. Metzl, Director, Vanderbilt Center for Medicine, Health, and Society, 2301 Vanderbilt Place, Nashville, TN 37235 (e-mail: jonathan.metzl@vanderbilt.edu).

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s